Monday, May 3, 2010

Graphical Debunking Of Gold-Bubble Claim

There are those who think that gold is in the climax of a bubble right now. In a Seeking Alpha article, Bruce Pile charts the gold market from 2001 to today and compares it with three bubbles that have come and gone: the NASDAQ (burst in 2000), the Nikkei (burst in 1990) and gold in its last bull market (burst in 1980.) His conclusion:
Long-term bull markets usually end in a parabolic rise. The chart above basically divides these bull markets into the relatively flat 8 to 12 year pre-parabolic phase and the 2 to 6 year parabolic rise. As the chart clearly shows, the current gold market is nowhere near the end phase of a historic bubble. In fact, it looks to be just now getting cranked up for that.

His own take pretty much squares with mine. Gold has yet to enter the parabolic rise of an all-out bubble, but it's getting primed for one. It's still advancing despite it being "unbelievably high."

Gold And Fiscal Crises, Present And Future

In his blog, Eric Roseman makes the point that gold isn't rising just because of inflation; it's rising because of the sovereign-debt crisis:
Gold is not in a bull market only because of inflation or fears thereof. It is rising because the big money knows that high levels of government indebtedness can't last indefinitely and that currency devaluations must accelerate if the global economy is to produce a sustainable expansion. Currency devaluations reduce purchasing power and produce long-term inflation. Also, major central banks in the United States, Europe and Japan will be slow to hike interest rates as consumption stalls and labor markets struggle to recover. Central bank policies will remain bullish for gold for the foreseeable future.

Therein lies a point for debate. Is gold discounting a rise in future inflation, which will be caused by partial monetization of sovereign debt being added to earlier monetary stimulus, or is inflation becoming irrelevant to gold's rise? The broader U.S. money supply measures are contracting, even though the narrower M1 had been expanding at a nice clip throughout the crisis. There are hints of inflation, but so far there's been no real upsurge. There hasn't been for about two years now. Nevertheless, gold is still rising.

Is it doing so on the strength of deficits leading to greater inflation, or is it doing so simply on the strength of the deficits? If the latter, then a resurgence of inflation is going to accelerate its rise.

April ISM Factory Index Up To 60.4%

Amongst other economic data, the Institute for Supply Management released its April figure; it's well into expansion territory. The reading of 60.4% is the highest it's been since June 2004, and was slightly above expectations.


Gold backed off a little after it was released, but that back-up was on the heel of a run that took the metal up to another 2010 high.

Stikcing For The Long Term: Why It's Hard

Howard Katz has penned an insightful article about sticking with the long-term trend. He brings up the point that people who stick for the long term do better than short-term traders, even though the latter take more profits, because the former's profits are large enough to compensate for the greater frequency of losses. The hard part comes with standing pat, though. Katz explains it as the fallacy of the fair price:
Intuitively, it seems quite reasonable to sell after a short term rise. But for the old timers (the chartists of the early 20th century), it was strictly an empirical question. Did it work out better to sell after a small rise or to hold on for a big move? To their surprise, the fellow who sold quickly (on the argument “you can’t take a loss taking a profit”) came out worse. The fellow who played for the big move came out better. Many times he took more profits than losses, but they were tiny profits (and big losses). The really successful traders often took more losses, but their profits were so big as to more than make up for it.

I have been fortunate enough to discover exactly why things are so counter-intuitive and why people are so anxious to sell too soon instead of holding on for the big move. One of the great thinkers of the 2nd millennium was a gentleman named Thomas Aquinas. He was a great man and very influential, but he lived in an ignorant time, and not much was known about economics. He argued that every good had a fair price. He confused what the price was going to be with what the price ought to be. Millions of people all over the world today follow his teachings. When they see a small rise in the good they are following, they decide that it is above its fair price....

He also says that the current bull market (if you peg '08's drop as a correction) has seen gold investors start off timid and get bolder later. Katz predicts that exploration stocks and silver are going to fly as the bull market matures.

Indian Wholesale Gold Demand Still Tepid

Acording to a report by the Economic Times, weak demand is now entering its second week.
"The dealing room is quiet today like it was for many days. There were a couple of deals here and there but nothing to write home about," said a dealer with a state-run bullion dealing bank in Mumbai.
A weakening rupee added to higher gold prices in draining demand

Gold Rises A Little As Concerns

A measure that rocked the gold market when first applied on January 11th, had no effect this time - just like the last time it was applied. Effective May 10th, the reserve ratio for mainland Chinese banks is going up once again by another 50 basis points. Gold had already sunk a little at the time of the announcement, and didn't fall when it was disseminated.

More effectual was worries about legislative roadblocks of the Eurobailout. The German legislature has yet to approve the German government's commitment, and the package might stall in that body. That potential stopping point primarily benefitted gold.

For most of the overnight session, the metal hovered between $1,177 and $1,179; as night turned into morning, the $1,179 ceiling moved down to $1,178. The metal didn't start rallying until about 5:00 AM ET, and then slowly. The rally picked up steam in the next two hours, peaking at $1,184.00 a little after 7:00 AM. Pulling back, the metal still stayed above $1,182. As of 8:08 AM, the spot price was at $1,182.70 for a gain of $3.40 since Friday's close. The Kitco Gold Index attributed -$3.50 to a strengthening greenback and +$6.90 to predominant buying.

The U.S. Dollar Index was up relative to Friday's close, but the gains were put in place last night. Rallying from below 81.8 starting at 8:00 PM, the Index got above 82.2 by 10:00. Subsequently, it traded in a range between 82.1 and 82.3, whose ceiling lowered to a little above 82.2 after 4:00. The typical inverse relationship between the greenback and gold reasserted itself somewhat overnight. As of 8:15, the Index was at 82.185.

A Reuters report ascribed gold's rise to skepticism over the bailout for the Grecian government, which first benefitted the U.S. dollar.
"The financial aid package is only buying time, the long-term problems still exist. It also seems that market players had expected a larger package," said Daniel Briesemann, commodity analyst at Commerzbank....

"There is still very strong safe haven demand for gold. It seems like investors are still nervous about what still might come despite the package for Greece. I wouldn't rule out that we might touch new highs in dollar-gold as well," a European trader said....
Also included is a forecast of $1261 gold, as based upon Reuters technical data.

The morning Bloomberg report, webbed earlier than the Reuters one by Business Week, was more skeptical, suggesting that gold may fall:
“We might see a bit of consolidation,” said Darren Heathcote, head of trading at Investec Bank (Australia) Ltd. in Sydney. Gold may have “the odd little bit of reversal,” said Heathcote....

“Quite often when we start to see uncertainties in the market, you get contagion across all markets, then you do sometimes see short-term selling,"...

Still, the precious metal is up 7.4 percent this year as “it seems to be benefitting at the moment from almost anything,” Heathcote said.

“Gold has taken on a positive tone and is unlikely to lose that going forward. On the one hand it benefits when we get a stronger euro, risk is on and everyone’s diversifying, on the other hand when things looks a bit unstable then we get safe- haven buying.”
That's what happened subsequently in early-morning trading.

As regular trading opened, gold slumped a bit; the U.S. Dollar Index stayed in its range. Starting at $1,182 as of 8:15, the metal first popped up and then fell to below $1,181. A rebound prefaced another drop to below $1,180.50; a see-sawing pattern took hold which got gold up above $1,181.50 before it pulled back again. As of 8:54, the spot price was $1,180.50 for a gain of $1.10 since Friday's close. The Kitco Gold Index attributed -$4.20' worth of change to a strengthening greenback and +$5.30' worth to predominant buying. The U.S. Dollar Index stayed in its range, although challenging it on the upside: as of 8:56, it was at 82.21.

So far, regular trading has been a bit of a letdown from the gains put on several hours earlier. It may set the tone for the rest of the day as profit-taking settles in.

Sunday, May 2, 2010

A Golden Bubble

This week's Financial Sense Newshour podcast had little to say on gold, So I'd like to discuss an article appearing in Stockhouse that discusses the potential of gold going in to an all-out bubble:

It's entitled "Gold price and 'the' parabolic peak." Its author, Dudley Pierce Baker, expects an imminent bubble in gold. Although it opens by debunking the claim that gold's in a bubble right now, the bulk of it is a review of two assets classes, a commodity, and two stocks that went parabolic in what were clearly bubbles. Four of them - the Nikkei, Toll Brothers stock, the NASDAQ 100 and crude oil - are charted before gold is brought in. The chart of the fifth, Homestake Mining in the 1930s, is shown after gold is discussed. The author's point is that, if gold goes into an all-out bubble starting now, the parabolic rise will be great enough to push the metal up to at least $2,450 an ounce and likely above $3,000.


That's what the author thinks. He could be right, as gold is beginning to act in unexpectedly bullish ways - most obviously, its rises in tandem with the U.S. dollar. The amount of fear that accompanied the December drop - in retrospect, a mere correction - was about the same as the level that accompanied the '08 financial panic.

Speaking of '08, I'd like to point out something that not many have, because the "nine-year bull market" characterization makes sense overall. Going by standard definitions, the bull market that began in '01 ended in early '08. The fall from $1,035 in February of '08 to $700 in October of that year was a 32.4% drop. Using the standard definition of a bear market, a drop of 20% or more, there was a gold bear market during the credit crunch. When over, gold entered into a new bull market. It started on October '08 at $700 and is currently less than two years old. By this interpretration, the "new gold bugs" have come in because of a new bull market getting rolling.

There is a parallel to gold in the '70s. The metal did see a drop of about 50% between 1974 and 1976, which would count as a severe bear market had it been the stock market. The 1976-1980 period saw the second gold bull market of the '70s.

Using this framework, the commodity cycle that we peg as a single bull market is really composed of two. The first one is longer, and starts off in general apathy. Gold starts off in the most encouraging contrarian environment of all: except for a dedicated few, no-one cares enough to be bullish or bearish. People who would otherwise have been bearish have consigned gold to the dustbin. So have a lot of people who wind up being bullish later. At the start, the buying of those few bulls is enough to move the metal upwards.

The best comparison would be to Wall Street in, say, 1949. Public sentiment wasn't overwhelmingly bearish; it was overwhelmingly dissociated. Bulls and bears are lumped together in the popular mind as belonging to a kind of cult. "Stocks? Why would anyone care outside of a Wall Street [you fill in]? Do I look like one of them to you?"

The first bull market proceeds in a draining of that apathy as more people discover the metal and its fundamentals. With respect to the gold cycle, the first bull ends when the fractional-reserve system is hit by an economic disaster that threatens to tip the economy into outright deflation. Yes, there were deflationists in the '70s - and their arguments are quite familiar to anyone following the inflation/deflation debate right now. An economic wound, such as the 1973-5 and current recessions, will precipitate massive money destruction caused by massive defaults. Scared, depositors will trigger bank runs that will overpower the Fed's response. It'll be like 1929-33 all over again.

For obvious reasons, the deflationistas enter in to the public consciousness. When the stock market's cracked and times are tough, "another Great Depression" finds a ready audience. Because of the economic gutting, the case for future inflation is easy to debunk. "Inflation how? Have you seen the unemployment figures? The unused capacity figures? With that kind of slack, inflation is yesterday's worry." Yes, those arguments were made in the mid-1970s too.

Consequently: the second bull market in the cycle begins with widespread skepticism. The first bull market feeds on the return of inflation, which becomes painfully evident at its peak. [Remember '07?] The second bull market, initially, feeds on reflation and goes into a parabolic peak when reflation turnes into an inflationary crisis.

What gives it is parabolic nature is, the skepticism barrier falls more easily than the indifference barrier. We're already seeing the gold skeptics fade away, and gold itself being mainstreamed for essentially pragmatic reasons. The first bull market, as compared with the range-bound behaviour of the stock market, makes for an easier sell than learned discourses on the nature and flaws of fiat currency. Once inflation returns, the bull market kicks into high gear and ends up in a parabolic ascent. The second bull market is the bubble.


Of course, it's easier to think of gold's bullish phase as comprising one large bull market with a vicious decline in the middle of it. The final push gibes well with standard characterizations of the third and final stage of a single bull market.

That being noted, I have another point to make: in all assets that have gone into bubbles, there's a pseudo-popping that scares the willies out of bulls and encourages a lot of skeptics to proclaim, "see? I told you it'd pop!" Yes, Internet stocks were besotten by that pseudo-popping in late '97 and early '98. David Dreman, in his Contrarian Investment Strategies: The Next Generation (1998), treated the Internet stock boom as a bubble that had come and gone.

The same pseudo-popping visited the oil market in late 2006. I have to admit to being caught out by that drop; I thought at the time that the big bull run was over. For a time, I was right - but, of course, I was proven to be wrong as the oil bubble got rolling again in '07.

Should gold go into a parabolic bull market, there almost certainly will be a fake-out drop like the Internet stocks suffered in '97-98 and oil went through in '06. This pseudo-popping will be widely vaunted as the end of the bubble, and lots of bulls will act as if they believed that to be the case. After all, common sense will say that gold went too far, too fast at that point; it'll look like a popped bubble for a time.

The only ones that'll stay steadfast, and loudly proclaim that gold is going back up, will be the "true believers." When it does, they'll be the ones who'll be right when a lot of others were wrong.

At this point, the final climax is on its way. Everyone except for true believers, who will become bankable, will have been shown up. At this stage, the credulous will be the big winners. Naive bullishness will look like genius.

It's at this point that the legendary shoeshine attendants, waiters, taxi drivers, homemakers, etc. will be bending people's ears about gold. What they'll see is the credulous and naive are really becoming rich simply by being gold hyperbulls. What better invitation could there be than seeing your likesake making easy money hand over fist?

At this point, the gold bubble is on its way to really popping. Sad to say, anyone who pulls out at this point is going to feel pretty stupid for doing so.


We're far from this stage yet, as many gold analysts have noted, but we may be in the next few years.